Other authentic Shia books on the subject of hadiths are “Osool Kafi” [17], “Bahar-al-Anwar” [22], “Tahzib Ol Ahkam” [23], “Hagh Ol Yaghin” [24], “Ghorar Ol Hekam & Dorar Ol Kalem” [25], and “Man La Yahzaroh Ol Faghih” [26]. (Table 2)
Discussion
Teachings in Islam have clear guidance for all aspects of life, including care for the family, sexual deviations, crime, racism, and suicide prevention [27]. Hadiths and traditions of Prophet Muhammad and Imams around the topic of suicide can be listed into three categories:
(A) Traditions and narratives expressing the prohibition of suicide [28-30].
(B) Hadiths and narratives demonstrating examples of suicide [31].
C) Traditions expressing the consequences of suicide in the Hereafter [32-34].
In what follows, we first elaborate on these hadiths and then discuss how to educate Muslims to prevent suicidal behaviors using these hadiths together with Quran verses.
Prohibition of suicide
God explicitly condemns suicide in verse 29 of Sura Nisa in Quran by saying, “Do not kill yourselves”. This implies that it is obligatory to abandon suicide. Therefore, one can concludes that suicide is absolutely forbidden in Islam. Prophet Muhammad and Imams have also condemned this practice in their hadiths. For example, Prophet Muhammad says, “There was a man before you live, he was hurt and he could not tolerate, so he took a knife and cut his hand, so he bled until he died, so God said: he hurried to kill himself, therefore, I forbade paradise for him.” [35] In another narration, Prophet Muhammad also was quoted as saying, “A man carried out suicide with a spear, then the Messenger of Allah said: I do not pray for him.” [28]
Prophet Muhammad also advised his followers not to wish for death. He says, “No one should wish for death because of the injury that he has been suffered.” [36] Furthermore, self-preservation and no self-harm are so important in Islam that according to Quran eating pork and dead animals are permissible in the emergencies, or if fasting is exhausting in Ramadan for Muslims they are allowed to break it any time [28]. As a result, Prophet Muhammad says “When preserving life is so important under the Islamic values, suicide is not acceptable at all.” [37, 18]
Imam Baqir also states, “A Muslim may be afflicted with any disasters or die because of any kind of deaths, but he will not carry out suicide’’ [38]. Imam Sadeq says, “Some of the biggest sins are as follows: i) Considering a partner for God; ii) Disappointment of God’s help; iii) Curse of parents; iv) Suicide and killing others [26]. Imam Sadeq also says, “Whoever encourages a suicide believer even with words, at the resurrection day appears in a way in which this message is written between his two eyes that he is disappointed with God's mercy.” [29]
It is clear that Prophet Muhammad and Imams advised to stop suicide, so to highlight the evil of the act, Prophet Muhammad did not pray for the person that killed himself [39]. Therefore, Under the Islamic Sharia, suicide is amongst the worst actions and the will of the person after suicide is not accepted [40]. Even from the perspective of Islam and the Imams, cooperating with a person who carries out suicide results in divine retribution.
Examples of suicide
Imam Sadeq quoted from Imam Ali that, “Whoever eats soil is contributing to kill himself”. Imam Sadeq further quoted from Imam Ali as saying, “Do not eat the soil because if you eat it and die you will be complicit in your murder (suicide).” Also, Imam Sadeq quoted Prophet Muhammad as saying, “Everyone who eats soil and dies he has helped in his suicide.” Imam Reza also states, “Eating soil is forbidden like eating carcass, blood, and pork, then avoid eating them.” [31] Unauthorized conflict with others is one of the examples of suicide, Sheikh Tabarsi quoted Imam Sadeq as saying, “Do not kill yourself except that God intended (do not suicide).
” [41]
The above divine guidelines indicate that eating the soil and unauthorized conflicts have been considered as the signs of suicides. Therefore, according to hadiths and traditions, eating anything harmful to human beings or any unauthorized conflicts are forbidden; and deliberately doing such acts are signs of suicide
.
Moreover, these hadiths are also related to suicide attempts. The results of a study entitled “Prohibition of suicide from the perspective of Islamic jurisprudence” points out that suicide is a prohibited act and some acts equal to suicide in Islam are: self-murder (killing oneself), killing others, committing sins, fighting with others, and self-harm [18].
The consequences of suicide
Suicide has severe individual, family, and social consequences [5, 6]. Each individual who carries out suicide according to religious hadiths are bound to suffer severe and painful punishments in the other world. Prophet Muhammad says, “Whoever carries out suicide by iron, will enter into the hell forever, while the iron is in his hand and part of it is into his belly. The one who carries out suicide e.g. by eating toxic materials, will enter into the hell and stay there forever, while that toxic material is in his hand. The one also carries out suicide e.g. by jumping from the mountain, then he will be thrown into hell and he will stay there forever.” [32]
He says in another narration, “Whoever carries out suicide by eating poisonous food, he will be suffered by the same poison”; and “Whoever carries out suicide by something, he will slaughter himself by the same thing in the hellfire.” [34] He declares, “Who kills himself with something in this world is tormented by the same thing on the resurrection day.” [30] He says in another narrative, “Who suffocates himself, will suffocate himself in the hell, and who spears himself will be in the fire in the hell.” [42] In another similar narration the Prophet Muhammad states, “A person who kills himself by something shall be tormented in the hell.” [43] Finally, Imam Sadeq says: “Whoever tries to carry out suicide, he will be ended in the hell.’’ [44]
Therefore, Islam has considered suicide to be an unforgivable sin [28, 45, 18, 46], and as per the narrations, the destination of the suicidal person is in the hell. Suicide is also a profane act in other religions, including Zoroastrianism [47]; Judaism [48- 49, 50-51]; and Christianity [52-53, 12]. Even in the past centuries, Christians were not allowed to bury the corpse of the person who carried out suicide in the church land.
Educating Muslims to prevent suicidal behaviors using hadiths and Quran verses
Islam offers valuable lessons on suicide prevention through hadiths and Quran verses. One would be able to fit these lessons into three levels of prevention, i.e. primary, secondary and tertiary [54]. For primary prevention, lessons may include those verses, hadiths, and narratives that aimed at reducing and eliminating the risk factors associated with suicide. The second level of suicide prevention highlights the role of religious scholars and clerics in detecting the most at risk people for carrying out the suicidal behavior [55-57]. The tertiary level of prevention includes recommendations in support, sympathy, and compassion for friends and relatives of those who carry out suicide.
Given the importance and vital role of primary prevention of suicidal behavior, in the final part of the article, we only focus on how to educate Muslims to primarily prevent suicidal behaviors using hadiths and Quran verses. As previously mentioned, the first level of suicide prevention may include those verses, hadiths, and narratives that points to the reduction and elimination of risk factors associated with suicide. Among vast arrays of suicide risk factors, we will only focus on depression and anxiety; alcohol consumption; and socio-economic factors and discuss how hadiths and Quran verses are able to prevent these risk factors of suicide among Muslims [58].
Depression and anxiety disorders are independent risk factors for suicide attempts [59, 60]. The word depression in the Quran has been used widely in connection with grief. Moreover, depression has also been expressed with words such as grief in the hadiths [61]. In verse 35, Sura “Araf”, God says, “Children of Adam, when messengers come to you from among yourselves, conveying My messages to you, then all who are mindful of Me and live righteously don't need to fear not will they grieve.” [37] In this verse, faith and self-behavior correction are cited as two main ways to reduce and treat depression from the Quran's perspective. It is also stated in part of one of Imam Ali's testament, “Depart from depression and sorrow with the power of patience and certainty.” [62] Nowadays, scientific studies have also found positive effects of Islamic education on treatment of depression. The results of a study by Shojaei et al. (2014) indicated that religious care of patients with depression was more effective than the control group without such religious care [63].
Similarly, alcohol use is associated with suicide behavior. Intoxicated people are more likely to attempt suicide using more lethal methods [64]. Religion beliefs are associated with lower levels of alcohol abuse [65]. In several verses in the Quran, drinking alcohol is forbidden. In verse 90, Sura “Maaida”, God says, “O ye who believe! Strong drink and games of chance and idols and divining arrows are only an infamy of Satan's handiwork. Leave it aside in order that ye may succeed.” [37] A man also asked Imam Sadeq, “Which one is the worse? Drinking alcohol or stopping to pray?” Imam said, “Drinking alcohol is worse than stopping to pray. Since, by drinking alcohol one does not recognize his dear God”. [22] In the United States, at least one-quarter of suicides are linked to drinking alcohol. In a cross-sectional study, the researchers concluded that there was a significant linear relationship between per capita alcohol consumption (beer type) in different countries and suicide rates in both men and women [66].
Finally, socio-economic factors, especially income inequality, have important roles in increasing the suicide rate [67]. The studies show that poverty is associated with suicide rates, with 75% of suicide occurring in the low and middle-income countries [68].
On the subject of poverty, God says in the Quran, “The Evil one threatens you with poverty and bids you to conduct unseemly
.”[37] Imam Ali says to his son, Imam Hassan Mujtaba about the consequences of poverty: “My child, who suffers from poverty has four traits: weakness in certainty, deficiency in reason, weakness in religion, and inferiority
.” [69] Religion can alleviate poverty in the community by affecting economic problems such as usury, bribery, and extortion. It can also indirectly prevent suicide by strengthening social capital [58, 70, 54].
Conclusion
Suicide is an absolute forbidden act in Islam, which has destructive consequences. According to the results of the present study, hadiths and traditions of Islamic religion about suicide can be classified into three categories which includes those prohibiting suicide, explaining the forms of suicide and the consequences of suicide. The religious hadiths in Islam could be effective in preventing suicide.
Acknowledgment
The authors would like to thank the Vice Chancellery for Research and Technology in Rafsanjan University of Medical Sciences.
Conflicts of interest
The authors have declared no conflict of interest for
this study.
References
[1] Uğur K, Demirkol ME, Tamam L. The mediating roles of psychological pain and dream anxiety in the relationship between sleep disturbance and suicide.
Archives of suicide research 2020; 1-17.
[2] Appleby L. Postgraduate psychiatry: clinical and scientific foundations. CRC Press; 2001.
[3] Organization W. Suicide. 2019. Retrieved from
https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/suicide
[4] Bertolote JM, Fleischmann A. A global perspective in the epidemiology of suicide.
Suicidologi 2002;
7 (2).
[5] Campos RC, Holden RR, Santos S. Exposure to suicide in the family: Suicide risk and psychache in individuals who have lost a family member by suicide.
Journal of clinical psychology 2018; 74 (3): 407-17.
[6] Spillane A, Matvienko-Sikar K, Larkin C, Corcoran P, Arensman E. What are the physical and psychological health effects of suicide bereavement on family members? An observational and interview mixed-methods study in Ireland.
BMJ open 2018
; 8 (1): e019472.
[7] Beautrais AL. Suicide in Asia. In: Hogrefe & Huber Publishers; 2006.
[8] Tureck G, Brent DA. Suicide and suicidal behaviour.
The Lancet 2016; 387 (10024): 1227-39.
[9] Gearing RE, Alonzo D. Religion and suicide: New findings.
Journal of religion health 2018; 57 (6): 2478-99.
[10] Benute GRG, Nomura RNY, Jorge VMF, Nonnenmacher D, Junior RF, de Lucia MSC, et al. Risk of suicide in high-risk pregnancy: an exploratory study.
Revista da Associação Médica Brasileira 2011; 57 (5): 570-574.
[11] Lawrence RE, Oquendo MA, Stanley B. Religion and suicide risk: a systematic review.
Archives of suicide research 2016; 20 (1): 1-21.
[12] Rezaeian M. A Narrative Review on Religion Epidemiology with Emphasis on Suicide Behavior.
Journal of Rafsanjan University of Medical Sciences 2018; 16 (9): 869-82.
[13] Pocock L, Rezaeian M. Medical Education and the Practice of Medicine in the Muslim countries of the Middle East.
World Family Medicine Journal: Incorporating the Middle East Journal of Family Medicine 2016
; 99 (3719): 1-11.
[14] Rezaeian M. Muslim world's universities: Past, present and future.
World Family Medicine Journal: Incorporating the Middle East Journal of Family Medicine 2016;
99 (3719): 1-3.
[15] Fouberg EH, Murphy AP. Human geography: people, place, and culture. John Wiley & Sons; 2020.
[16] Kettani H. 2010 world muslim population. Paper presented at the proceedings of the 8th Hawaii Internafional Conference on Arts and Humanifies. 2010.
[17] Kulayni MIY. Usul al-Kafi. Tehran: Office of Islamic History and Education Studies; 2000.
[18] Shafiee Mazandarani SM. Prohibition of suicide from the perspective of Islamic jurisprudence.
Jurisprudential research 2010; 6 (1): 39-53 [Persian].
[19] Rezaeian M, Vazirinejad R, Tabatabie S, Salem Z, Esmaili A. Suicide in Islamic faith.
Journal of Rafsanjan University of Medical Sciences 2007; 6 (4): 15-30.
[20] Sabry WM, Vohra A. Role of Islam in the management of psychiatric disorders.
Indian journal of psychiatry 2013; 55 (Suppl 2): S205.
[21] Sadr Huseini A. Authenticity of traditions of the four books of Shiite hadith.
MAQALAT WA BARRASIHA 2006; 79 (39): 101-28 [Persian].
[22] Majlesi MB. Bahar al-Anwar. Tehran: Islamic Publications; 2016.
[23] Tusi AJMIH. Tahzib Ol Ahkam. Beirut: Dar al-Azva; 2005.
[24] Majlesi MB. Hagh Ol Yaghin. Tehran: Islamieh; 1984.
[25] Amadi Tamimi AW. Ghorar Ol Hekam Dorar Ol Kalem. Qom: Dar Alketab Eslamieh; 1990.
[26] Ibn Babawayh al-Qummi AJMIA. Man La YahduruhuAl-Faqih. Vol. 3. Qom: Islamic Publishing Institute; 1993.
[27] El Azayem GA, Hedayat-Diba Z. The psychological aspects of Islam: Basic principles of Islam and their psychological corollary.
The International Journal for the Psychology of Religion 1994; 4 (1): 41-50.
[28] Al-Mubarakafori MARBAR. Tohfat Al Ghozi. Beirut: Dar Al Ketabol Elmieh; 1935.
[29] Al-Qazwīnī AMIYIMR. Sunan Ibn Mājah. Lebanon: Daroljeil; 1998.
[30] Darimi ABAM. Sunan al-Darimi
. Moderation Edition ed. Vol. 15. Damascus: Treasure of Workers; 2000.
[31] Al-Aamili SAH. Wasa'il al-Shia: Al-Bayt. 1984.
[32] Nishapuri MIAH. Sahih Muslim Be Sharh Al-Nawawi.Vol. 18. Beirut: Dar Al-Fakr; 9th century.
[33] Rawandi QAD. Al-Kharaiji and Al-Jawareh. First Edition ed. Qom: The Imam Al-Mahdi Foundation (AJ); 1989
[34] Tabrani SBABA. Al Moaajem ol Alkabir. Second edition ed. Vol. 25. Cairo: Darayyaa of Arab; 1994.
[35] Isfahani IBMBFJ. Al-Targhib and Al-Tarhib.Vol. 3. Beirut; 1988.
[36] Mohammadi Rey Shahri M. Hekmat Nameh Prophet (PBUH). Vol. 4. Qom (Iran): Dar Al-Hadith Scientific and Cultural Institute; 2007.
[37] Hashemi Rafsanjani A. Guide to Interpretation. First Edition ed. Vol. 3. Qom: Islamic Propagation Office; 1999.
[38] Amili, ASAHA. Wasa'il al-Shi'a. Vol. 10. Qom: Manshurat Dhawi l-Qurba; 2008.
[39] Khomeini MHBH. Tozihol Al Masaeal Marajeh. Vol. 1. Qom: Qom Seminary Teachers Association; 2007.
[40] Mortazi A, Nalbandi Aqdam M. The effect of suicidal attempts on legal status of will with a critical approach to Article 836 of the Civil Code.
Islamic jurisprudence research 2019; 15 (1): 165-186 [Persian].
[41] Al-Tabrisi, AAFBAḤBAF. Majma' al-bayan fi tafsir al-Qur'an. Beirut: Dar Al Maerefeh; 1986.
[42] Husam AIAAM. Kanz al-Ummal.Vol. 15. 1472 CE - 1567 CE.
[43] Nawawi YBSAD. Sahih Muslim be Sharh al-Nawawi. Second Edition ed. Vol. 2. Beirut: Dar Al-Ketab Al-Arabi; 1972.
[44] Sheikh Kalini AY. Al Frogh men Al Kafi. Third edition ed. Vol. 7. Tehran: Islamic Book House; 1988.
[45] Javadi Amoli A. Tafsir Tasnim. Vol. 19. Qom: Asra Publishing Center; 2010.
[46] Asgaeri R. Prohibition of Suicide in the Quran and Tradition, and Quranic Strategies for its Prevention.
Interdisciplinary Quranic studies 2014 1 (5): 103-130 [Persian].
[47] Rezi H. Avesta. Tehran: Forouhar Publications; 1995.
[48] Barry R. The biblical teachings on suicide.
Ssues L 1997;
13: 283.
[49] Behrooz A. Recognizing the Ten Commandments in the Torah and the Qur'an after the Middle Ages: The Doctrine of the Faith.
MARIFAT-I ADYAN 2013; 4 (2):
25-38
[50] Gvion Y, Levi-Belz Y, Apter A. Suicide–The Jewish Perspective.
Crisis 2014; 35 (3): 141-144.
[51] Davies G, Magness J. Recovering Josephus: Mason’s History of the Jewish War and the Siege of Masada.
Scripta Classica Israelica 2017; 36: 55-65.
[52] Vijayakumar L, Pirkis J, Huong TT, Yip P, Seneviratne RDA, Hendin H. Socio-economic, cultural and religious factors affecting suicide prevention in Asia.
Suicide prevention in Asia 2018; 19-29.
[53] Gearing RE, Lizardi D. Religion and suicide.
Journal of religion health 2009; 48(3): 332-341.
[54] Khosroshahi G, Javadi Hosseini Abadi H. An Analysis on the Relationship between Religious Identity and the Prevention of Crime.
Criminal Law Research 2017; 5 (17): 91-125. doi:10.22054/jclr.2017.7121
[55] Hamidi F, Bagherzadeh Z, Gafarzadeh SJPS. The role of Islamic education in mental health.
Procedia-Social Behavioral Sciences 2010; 5: 1991-1996.
[56] Hirono T. The role of religious leaders in suicide prevention: A comparative analysis of American Christian and Japanese Buddhist clergy.
SAGE Open 2013; 3 (2): 2158244013486992.
[57] Organization WH. National suicide prevention strategies - Progress, examples and indicators. 2018.
[58] Elmi G, Shavarani M. The function of beliefs and Islamic rites in reducing suicide.
Mirror of Wisdom 2012; 3: 163-89 [Persian].
[59] Bolton JM, Cox BJ, Afifi TO, Enns MW, Bienvenu OJ, Sareen J. Anxiety disorders and risk for suicide attempts: findings from the Baltimore Epidemiologic Catchment area follow‐up study.
Depression and anxiety 2008; 25 (6): 477–81.
https://doi.org/10.1002/da.20314
[60] Roose SP, Glassman AH, Walsh BT, Woodring S, Vital-Herne J. Depression, delusions, and suicide.
Am J Psychiatry 1983; 140 (9): 1159-62.
[61] Taghipur H. Depression and its Removal Factors as Mental Health Indicators, From the Viewpoint of Holy Quran.
Islamic Life Journal 2016; 1(4): e16361.
[62] Abi Talib AI. Nahj al-Balagheh. Vol. 12. Tehran: Sarayi Publications; 1979.
[63] Shojaei S, Abbasi M, Rahimi T, Vahedian M, Farhadloo R, Movahed E, et al. The Effect of Religious Care by the Clergyman next to the Patients’ Bedside on their Depression and Anxiety.
Journal of Research on Religion Health 2018; 4 (3): 45-55.
[64] Sher L. Alcohol consumption and suicide.
Qjm 2006; 99 (1): 57-61.
[65] Michalak L, Trocki K, Bond J. Religion and alcohol in the US National Alcohol Survey: how important is religion for abstention and drinking?
Drug alcohol dependence 2007;
87 (2-3): 268-80.
[66] Roche SP, Rogers ML, Pridemore WA. A cross-national study of the population-level association between alcohol consumption and suicide rates.
Drug alcohol dependence 2018; 188: 16-23.
[67] Curtis B, Curtis C, Fleet RW. Socio-economic factors and suicide: The importance of inequality.
New Zealand Sociology 2013; 28 (2): 77.
[68] Iemmi V, Bantjes J, Coast E, Channer K, Leone T, McDaid D, et al. Suicide and poverty in low-income and middle-income countries: a systematic review.
The Lancet Psychiatry 2016; 3 (8): 774-83.
[69] Nuri HBM. Mustadrak al-wasa'il; Beirut: Alelbeit Institute; 1988.
[70] Wu A, Wang JY, Jia CX. Religion and completed suicide: A meta-analysis.
PloS one 2015; 10 (6): e0131715